Put each proposal on the same page.
Use one column for each contractor and compare the same roof sections, material specification and responsibilities. Mark missing information as “ask,” rather than assuming it is included. Read our map flashing and roof transitions before accepting a scope for a practical record to use with the written scope.
| Question | Proposal A | Proposal B |
|---|---|---|
| Roof areas & removal layers | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Covering & underlayment | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Flashing, vents & edges | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Deck repair allowance | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Permits & inspections | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Cleanup & protection | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Schedule & weather plan | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Price, exclusions & changes | Included / ask | Included / ask |
| Warranty & completion records | Included / ask | Included / ask |
Resolve the unknowns.
A proposal may include an allowance for work that cannot be confirmed until removal. Ask how the condition will be documented, who authorizes additional work and which unit prices apply. A clear change process matters as much as the initial total.
- Covering — the named product and attachment details.
- Underlayment — the layer below the covering, specified as part of the system.
- Decking — the supporting surface, with hidden-condition allowances made clear.
Conceptual layers, not an installation detail. Flashings, edges, penetrations and ventilation also belong in the written scope.
Separate the promises.
Product warranties and contractor workmanship warranties cover different things. Request the actual written terms, exclusions, claim process and any transfer conditions. Do not rely on the word “lifetime” without its conditions.
Your comparison checklist
- Scope: which roof sections, removal layers and exclusions are included?
- Decking: how will hidden damage be documented, priced and approved?
- System: exact covering, underlayment, flashings, ventilation and accessories.
- Requirements: applicable product approvals, attachment details and permits.
- Protection: landscaping, driveway, attic contents, weather plan and cleanup.
- Schedule: anticipated start, duration, weather delays and point of contact.
- Price: itemized total, allowances, payment milestones and change procedure.
- Warranty: product versus workmanship terms, exclusions and transfer rules.
- Closeout: final inspection, permit record, product records and warranty papers.
Prepare my quote questions to keep your questions together. The planner creates no dollar estimate and does not recommend a contractor. If recommendations conflict, use our roof replacement second-opinion evidence checklist to separate observations from assumptions.
Florida contractor license search (opens in a new tab) · Florida Product Approval search (opens in a new tab)